Eight spinel single-crystal samples belonging to the spinel sensu stricto-magnesiocoulsonite series (MgAl₂O₄-MgV₂O₄) were synthesized and crystal-chemically characterized by X‑ray diffraction, electron microprobe and optical absorption spectroscopy. Site populations show that the tetrahedrally coordinated site (T) is populated by Mg and minor Al for the spinel sensu stricto compositions, and only by Mg for the magnesiocoulsonite compositions, while the octahedrally coordinated site (M) is populated by Al, V³⁺, minor Mg, and very minor amounts of V⁴⁺. The latter occurs in appreciable amounts in the Al-free magnesium vanadate spinel, T(Mg)M(Mg_0.26V³⁺_1.48V⁴⁺_0.26)O₄, showing the presence of the inverse spinel VMg₂O₄. The studied samples are characterized by substitution of Al³⁺ for V³⁺ and (Mg²⁺+V⁴⁺) for 2V³⁺ described in the system MgAl₂O₄-MgV₂O₄-VMg₂O₄.

The present data in conjunction with data from the literature provide a basis for quantitative analyses of two solid-solution series MgAl₂O₄-MgV₂³⁺O₄ and MgV₂³⁺O₄-V⁴⁺Mg₂O₄. Unit-cell parameter increases with increasing V³⁺ along the series MgAl₂O₄-MgV₂O₄ (8.085–8.432 Å), but only slightly increases with increasing V³⁺ along the series VMg₂O₄-MgV₂O₄ (8.386–8.432 Å). Although a solid solution could be expected between the MgAl₂O₄ and VMg₂O₄ end-members, no evidence was found. Amounts of V⁴⁺ are nearly insignificant in all synthetic Al-bearing vanadate spinels, but are appreciable in Al-free vanadate spinel.

An interesting observation of the present study is that despite the observed complete solid-solution along the MgAl₂O₄-MgV₂O₄ and MgV₂O₄-VMg₂O₄ series, the spinel structure seems to be unable to stabilize V⁴⁺ in any intermediate members on the MgAl₂O₄-Mg₂VO₄ join even at high oxygen fugacities. This behavior indicates that the accommodation of specific V-valences can be strongly influenced by crystal-structural constraints, and any evaluation of oxygen fugacities during mineral formation based exclusively on V cation valence distributions in spinel should be treated with caution. The present study underlines that the V valency distribution in spinels is not exclusively reflecting oxygen fugacities, but also depends on activities and solubilities of all chemical components in the crystallization environment.